Stanford, are you awake?

A message to Silicon Valley and beyond

Outside this campus, something is happening that is too loud to ignore. AI’s development accelerates while democratic institutions erode. Wars are processed through language models. Tech workers are laid off in the name of AI automation. College graduates are competing with the AI hype for entry-level positions.

Our group was born to address this momentum. It was born from the shared conviction that the rapid development of AI must be met with equally rigorous critical inquiry into how these technologies reshape power, equity, and governance. It was born of serendipitously crossing paths with people across generations and disciplines, and realizing we shared the same cognitive dissonance: what was happening outside campus was too loud to be ignored in classrooms.

Stanford holds significant normative power to shape our collective technological and political reality. We did not find each other through a formal call; rather, we met through the shared discomfort and hope that our collective energy could be the basis of inquiry and change.

We call our manifesto a Manyfesto as it was crafted with multiple hands.1 This is our opening statement. It is not the final word. It is an invitation to seize the momentum.


On the Moment We Are In

we write from Stanford, not a neutral location.

We write from Stanford, which is not a neutral location. There is no Silicon Valley without Stanford, and no Stanford without Silicon Valley. From lean start-ups to foundation models, the very grammar of disruption was codified on this campus. Stanford trades as much in narrative diffusion as in capital. It holds real epistemic power over how AI is understood, built, and adopted worldwide. Likewise, we recognize what Stanford embodies. Stanford’s own history renders its neutrality impossible. From dispossessed Indigenous land to eugenicist experimentation, power has largely flowed in one direction, towards racial, power, and wealth concentration. We believe it can be redirected. Critical AI exists to redirect Stanford’s authority toward public value, democratic accountability, and equitable AI governance.

We write from a pivotal time of political and social unrest. In the United States and in the world, democratic institutions are eroding. Polarized discourses fuel anti-democratic movements. Tech manifestos recently released from Silicon Valley intend to mainstream techno-fascist and white supremacist ideologies, justified on the basis of the AI arms race and imperialist claims. Again, we can course-correct. This is not the only trajectory. Other narratives exist within Stanford and Silicon Valley. Here and around the world, the tide is already turning. From AI resistance reading lists to tech workers unionizing to the Vatican questioning the neutrality of AI discourse, people with differing sets of values are defying the self-serving AI sales pitch. AI’s trajectory is not inevitable. Our responsibility is to question the stories that make it appear so. From Business to Law Schools, it is no longer credible to unquestionably drink the AI Kool-Aid.

What We Believe

What we stand on

1. AI is a socio-political technology. AI development does not emerge in a vacuum. It is co-produced by the institutions, labor arrangements, and political economies surrounding it. Treating AI as a purely technical phenomenon, a set of capabilities to be celebrated or feared in the abstract, mistakes its nature and disarms our response to it. Preventing AI harms and risks goes beyond technical intervention. While evaluations, red teaming, and benchmarks are useful tools, they can only be effective when targeting the right set of social issues and meeting mandatory regulatory compliance.

2. AI should be governed as a normal technology.2 We believe AI should be treated like other general-purpose technologies, such as electricity, aviation, and the internet: subject to gradual diffusion, sector-specific regulation, and human control, rather than as a rogue superintelligent entity operating outside the reach of existing institutional frameworks.

3. AI’s trajectory is not predetermined. The dominant narrative presents AI’s development as a force of nature: inevitable, exponential, beyond democratic reach. We reject the grammar of inevitability. As Terry Winograd observed, deciding is a computational activity, something that can ultimately be programmed; choice is the product of judgment, not calculation. The difference between deciding and choosing lies between submitting to an algorithm and exercising human agency. We are here to defend that distinction, and to insist that the choices being made about AI, by firms, by states, by universities, are choices, not computations, and must answer to those they affect.

4. To be critical of AI is to be reasonable. Our inquiry is not guided by nostalgia, fear, or resentment but by the desire to scrutinize any powerful system. We ask who benefits and who bears the costs of this technology. We reject the charge of technophobia. Our critique is not a rejection of technology; it is a demand for accountability. Critical inquiry is necessary if AI is to serve public value rather than concentrate corporate power.

5. To be critical of AI is to question power and information asymmetries. It means asking the questions industry narratives often avoid: Whose interests does AI amplify? Whose futures does it foreclose? Whose labor does it conceal? And which alternatives does it render unthinkable? Critique helps us hold contradictions in view long enough to preserve nuance and still gain the clarity to act.

6. The most important AI harms are currently hidden. Mainstream AI discourse is being co-opted by the disproportionate funding from entities with corporate conflicts of interest, such as AI labs, big tech, and effective altruist groups. Attention must be given to these funding sources: how they normalize AI discourse, direct our attention, and shape policy agendas. Currently, disproportionate attention is given to speculative risks such as longtermism, superintelligence, and catastrophic threats, instead of AI’s material consequences: mass domestic and foreign surveillance, militarization, environmental degradation from data centers, harms to children and vulnerable users through AI sycophancy, and the exploitation of hidden labor across the Global Majority. These concrete harms are strategically buried and need to be resurfaced for intervention.

What We Are Not

critique ≠ rejection

We are not technophobic. We are not calling for a ban, a moratorium, or a return to analog. We believe critique alone is insufficient. We deconstruct in order to reconstruct.

We are not naive about power. This group exists within an institution deeply entangled with the AI industry. We do not claim to stand outside of it. We claim to name these ties to resist its gravitational pull and conformist thinking.

We are conscious of our own power. We are conscious that we are operating in an environment that did not expect us to emerge, but also where our critical thinking is perhaps most necessary.

What We Are Doing

three pillars of inquiry and action.

The Stanford Critical AI Group has three pillars:

1) Community. We are building an interdisciplinary community of critical thinkers across campus, ranging from undergrads to faculty. We nurture an environment where difficult questions can be asked safely, with compassion and empathy. While our group is focused on Stanford affiliates, we welcome critical discussion and collaboration with like-minded groups beyond campus.

2) Research. We have launched working groups to advance scholarly AI research. Our groups are currently investigating the political economy of AI; surveillance pricing; the history and ideology of tech manifestos; and alternative AI regulatory frameworks that prioritize the governance of AI as a normal technology.

3) Advocacy. We are prototyping forms of resistance through workshops and convenings. We bring missing voices and debates to campus, and collectively re-write the language of resistance through our AI Solidarity Lexicon.

Our Invitation

an opening, not a closing

This is a Manyfesto, written by “many” of us. It is an opening, a question, a dance. An invitation to shape our common trajectory. We invite scrutiny, revision, and disagreement. We embrace debate and discomfort, as it’s the only way to provoke change. What is not optional, at this stage, is critical engagement. We are at a pivotal time, where the choices being made now, about how AI is built, deployed, governed, and narrated, will shape the world for decades. Stanford plays a role and we have decided to step in.

So, Stanford, are you awake?

We critique in order to act.

We deconstruct in order to reconstruct.

Drafted collectively Revised continuously

Stanford, 2026

Want to sign the Manyfesto or share feedback?

Sign or give feedback  →

1 Through this format, we build upon the path laid by our peers from the Decolonial AI Manyfesto, who first coined this term: manyfesto.ai

2 For foundational critiques about the socio-technical power structures complicating the framing of AI as a “normal technology”, see the work of Lucy Suchman, Terry Winograd, and Karen Hao. These perspectives sit alongside the more specific argument advanced by Arvind Narayanan and Sayash Kapoor that AI should be managed as a “normal technology” through standard, sector-specific regulation.

Signed by

Adrian Gamarra Lafuente Master's Student, Computer Science, Stanford
Angela Nguyen Undergraduate, Computer Science, Stanford
Aube Tollu Postdoc, Stanford
Sacha Alanoca PhD Student, Stanford
Faye-Marie Vassel Postdoc, Stanford
Chijioke Mgbahurike Stanford Critical AI
Archit Lohani Law Student, Stanford
Zaid Akhtar CS & History, Stanford
Dominic Zappia Stanford Tech Ethics & Policy
Juan S. Gómez-Cañón Postdoc, Stanford
Avi Udash Master's Student, Computer Science, Stanford
Franklin Liu Student, Stanford
David Palumbo-Liu Professor, Stanford
Angèle Christin Associate Professor of Communication, HAI Senior Fellow, Stanford
Lucy Suchman Professor Emerita, Lancaster University
Terry Winograd Professor Emeritus of Computer Science, Stanford University
James Garforth Lecturer, Assistant Professor, University of Edinburgh
Anastasia Karagianni Independent Researcher, DATAWO
Mallen Clifton PhD Candidate, Stanford University
Stuti Desai Undergraduate Student, Stanford
Vryan Feliciano Alumni, Stanford University
Jennifer Pfister MIT Media Lab
Meriem Mehri PhD Student, Polytechnique Montréal
Ismael Kherroubi Garcia Independent Researcher, Kairoi
Brandon Thai Tran Independent Researcher
Theresa Willem Postdoctoral Researcher, University of Cambridge
Meem Arafat Manab Early-Stage Researcher, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid
Kristoffer Ørum PhD Student, Copenhagen University
Firuza Huseynova M.A. Student, McGill University
Maroussia Lévesque Assistant Professor of Law & AI, Queen’s University
Josefina Miro Quesada Gayoso JSM / JSD, Stanford Law School
Jan Hauters Researcher & PhD Student, UCL IOE CCM Knowledge Lab
Halkano Boru Graduate Student, Stanford University
Michael Ross McCarrin Assistant Professor, Oberlin College
Nuoyi Wang PhD Candidate, University of Amsterdam
Marianne Lumeau Associate Professor of Digital Economics, University of Rennes, France
Mobina Riazi Graduate Student, Stanford University
Andres Burbano Associate Professor, UOC
Suraj Mirpuri Founder, Lowdown Labs
Nadia Guerouaou Postdoctoral Researcher, Centre Internet et Société, CNRS, Paris, France
Taras Kovalchuk De.Fi
David Evan Harris Chancellor’s Public Scholar, University of California, Berkeley
Julien Falgas Associate Professor, Center de recherche sur les médiations, University of Lorraine, France
Stephen Starkey Software Engineer
Kiito Shilongo Independent Researcher & Organiser
Manon Berriche Postdoctoral Researcher, médialab, Sciences Po
Georgia Walker-Keleher Master’s Student, Stanford
JS Tan PhD Student, MIT
Clarissa Redwine Organizer, Collective Action in Tech
Geneviève Smith Postdoctoral Fellow, Stanford University
Andrea Rosales Associate Professor, Universitat Oberta de Catalunya
Adrien Tallent Postdoctoral Researcher, Sorbonne Université
Viktor Udbye Author & Independent Researcher, MA in Philosophy
Anna Zenz Lecturer, University of Western Australia
Faheem Yunus CTO & Independent Researcher, Nuvint Dynamics
Salma Doghraji Engineering Manager, Google
Antonis Krasakis AI Research Scientist
Louis Ravn PhD Candidate, University of Amsterdam
Christoffer Koch Andersen PhD Student, University of Cambridge
Daniela Cotimbo Art curator & Professor, Re:humanism
Deepika Raman AI Governance Researcher, Independent
Hajar Azell Writer
Alexander Hurst Columnist, The Guardian
Louis Saha Undergraduate Student, King’s College London
Angelica Ferrara Affiliate Scholar, London School of Economics; formerly Postdoctoral Fellow, Clayman Institute for Gender Research, Stanford
Vinh Van AI Scientist, VN-UK Research Institute, University of Da Nang
João Galego Head of AI, Critical Software
Rupa Dachere CEO, Thrive-WiSE; Stanford LEAD Alumna, 2024
Alex Moltzau AI Policy, AI Norway – Government AI Unit (personal capacity)
Jane Wong Attorney, Legal Link
Kehan Sheng PhD Student, University of British Columbia
Lieve Vereycken Co-Designer, Co-Inpetto
Jèf Davis CEO, TELEMETRY
Wenshan Jia Professor of Communication, Chapman University
Graham Lovelace Editor & Publisher, Charting Gen AI
Scott Robson Responsible AI, Pathfinder Consulting, LLC
Carlo Santagiustina Researcher and Faculty Member, Inria Paris & Sciences Po médialab
Johanna Cordova Inalco
Andrea Gacanin PhD Student, Université Paris 8
Luc Rocher Associate Professor, Oxford Internet Institute, University of Oxford
Sarah Nicole Lecturer, Sciences Po
Gokhan Akdag Doctoral Researcher, Sabanci Business School
Natalie Maharaj Director ICT, Government of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago
Jean-Philippe Cointet Professor, Sciences Po
Alexi Orchard University of Notre Dame
Gwénaëlle André Postdoctoral Researcher, Concordia University
Nicolas Blanc Expert, GPAI
Ninell Oldenburg PhD Fellow, University of Copenhagen
Marc Rotenberg Founder, Center for AI and Digital Policy
Kiara Baker PhD Candidate, Carnegie Mellon University
Jo Tiffe Media Artist & Designer, Lause e.V., Berlin, Germany
Orfeas Menis Mastromichalakis Postdoc, Instituto de Telecomunicações, Lisbon
Daniel Cardoso Llach Associate Professor, Carnegie Mellon University
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
Ariam Mogos Lecturer, Stanford University
Tessa Holtzman PhD Candidate, Stanford
Lorena Martin Rodriguez PhD Student, Stanford University
Frank McGillicuddy Director, M&G DAG
Hannah Sheeran Senior Content Designer
Anonymous
Luc Hanneuse Manager, AgriLab Innovation Center & FabLab, AgriLab UniLaSalle
Shashika Bandara Senior Lecturer, Monash University
Pierre Noro Lecturer & Tech & Global Affairs Innovation Hub Advisor, Sciences Po Paris
Sarah T. Roberts Professor, UCLA
Safiya U. Noble Professor, Center on Resilience & Digital Justice
Paulo Carvao Research Fellow, Mossavar-Rahmani Center for Business and Government, Harvard Kennedy School
Sanjana Paul PhD Student, MIT
Théophile Pénigaud de Mourgues Postdoctoral Researcher, Sciences Po / Yale
John C. Havens Author, Heartificial Intelligence: Embracing Our Humanity to Maximize Machines
Emin PhD Student, University of Sussex
Kavita Vedhara Professor of Health Psychology, Cardiff University, UK
Anonymous
Sachidanand Mangala Basavanna Founder & Architect
Anonymous
Antonio Nuzzo Retired
Daniel Mwesigwa PhD Student, Cornell
Francesco Sticchi Senior Lecturer in Film Studies, Oxford Brookes University
Anonymous
Sarabjit Babeja Fellow, Distinguished Careers Institute
Patricia S. Sánchez-Muros Associate Professor, Department of Sociology, University of Granada
Jasmine Cha Community Advocacy Fellow, Internet Society
Grace Julius Computer Science Undergrad, Lincoln University of Pennsylvania
Dawid Bastiat-Jarosz Fellow, Center for Finance and Development, Geneva Graduate Institute
Jemima Gibbons Anthropologist, Sticks & Stones
Christy Grace Provines Founder | Executive Director, The ‘MPOWER Project
Evan Randle Undergraduate Student, University of Wisconsin-Madison